⚖️ SEC drops case against Gemini

In partnership with

SEC Dismissal: A High-Water Mark for Restitution-Led Leniency

The Securities and Exchange Commission’s decision this past Friday to drop its civil enforcement action against Gemini marks a significant turning point for the digital asset landscape. The dismissal, filed with prejudice in the Southern District of New York, effectively ends the long-standing dispute over the Gemini Earn program, which saw billions of investor funds locked after the collapse of Genesis Global Capital. The SEC specifically cited the 100 percent in-kind return of assets to Earn participants as the primary catalyst for its "exercise of discretion," signalling that full restitution has become the gold standard for avoiding federal penalties in the current regulatory climate. This move not only clears a major legal shadow from the Winklevoss brothers' exchange but also reinforces the federal government’s shift toward a more accommodative stance following the twins' vocal and financial support for the current administration.

Regulatory Pivot: The "Project Crypto" Era and the Atkins SEC

Under the leadership of Chairman Paul Atkins, who took the helm in early 2025, the SEC has fundamentally restructured its approach to the industry through what has been dubbed "Project Crypto." This case is just the latest in a sweeping series of retreats; the agency has now dismissed or significantly reduced penalties in over 60 percent of the crypto-related lawsuits inherited from the previous administration, including major actions against Coinbase and Binance. Unlike the "regulation by enforcement" era of the early 2020s, the current mandate focuses on "genuine harm" and bad actors rather than registration technicalities, essentially rewarding companies that successfully navigate bankruptcy or state-level settlements to make their users whole. For the broader ecosystem, this suggests that the era of aggressive federal litigation for non-fraudulent registration failures is effectively over, provided the "bread-and-butter" investor protections remain intact.

The Public Transition: Gemini Space Station and the Florida "Moonbase"

This dismissal arrives at a critical moment as the exchange, now operating under the corporate banner Gemini Space Station, solidifies its position as a publicly traded entity on the Nasdaq. Having raised $425 million in its September 2025 debut, the company is now navigating a strategic relocation of its core retail operations to a Florida-based entity affectionately named "Moonbase" to bypass New York’s notoriously stringent BitLicense requirements. By resolving the SEC's remaining claims, the Winklevoss twins have removed the final regulatory hurdle that had dampened institutional appetite and weighed on the GEMI stock price. Founders should view this as a clear signal that the regulatory risk premium for crypto is being re-priced, with the SEC now serving more as a collaborative reformer than a litigious gatekeeper, provided you maintain high-transparency standards and keep your users' wallets full.

In addition to our newsletter we offer 60+ free legal templates for companies in the UK, Canada and the US. These include employment contracts, investment agreements and more