⚖️ Reid Hoffman leads SV against Trump

In partnership with

Silicon Valley’s Moral Standoff: Hoffman vs. The Fence-Sitters

The tension in Silicon Valley has reached a breaking point as Reid Hoffman leads a high-profile charge against what he calls the "bending of the knee" to the Trump administration. Following the fatal January 2026 shootings of two American citizens, Alex Pretti, a 37-year-old VA nurse, and Renee Nicole Good, a mother of three, by federal agents in Minneapolis, the industry is split between vocal moral condemnation and calculated corporate silence. Hoffman’s core argument, outlined in his recent column for The San Francisco Standard, is that "neutrality" in the face of what he terms "performative brutality" is actually a proactive choice that invites further overreach. While many CEOs have issued memos calling for "de-escalation," Hoffman and peers like Vinod Khosla are demanding a direct confrontation with the White House, arguing that the security of both citizens and the business environment is at stake.

The Minneapolis Flashpoint: Pretti and Good

The catalyst for this unrest was Operation Metro Surge, a federal immigration crackdown that turned deadly in the first weeks of the new year. Alex Pretti was killed on January 24th while filming federal agents with his phone; although he was a licensed gun owner, video evidence suggests he was holding only his cell phone when agents fired at least ten times. This followed the January 7th killing of Renee Good, another U.S. citizen, which had already ignited protests across the Twin Cities. The administration's response, branding Pretti an "agitator" and claiming the agents were the true victims, has created a narrative gap that tech leaders find increasingly difficult to bridge, especially as graphic videos of the incidents continue to circulate on platforms like X.

The "Melania" Screening Backlash

The debate over tech leaders' proximity to power was crystallized by the optics of a private White House screening for an Amazon-backed documentary about First Lady Melania Trump. Just hours after the Pretti shooting, Apple CEO Tim Cook, Amazon CEO Andy Jassy, and AMD CEO Lisa Su were photographed attending the event alongside director Brett Ratner and other VIPs. This appearance has drawn fierce criticism from activists and employees alike, who view it as a jarring contradiction to the "heartbroken" memos these leaders sent to their staff. For critics like Hoffman, attending a celebratory movie night hosted by an administration currently embroiled in a domestic shooting controversy is the ultimate example of the "pacification" he warned against.

In addition to our newsletter we offer 60+ free legal templates for companies in the UK, Canada and the US. These include employment contracts, investment agreements and more