⚖️ Midjourney launches defence to copyright lawsuit

Midjourney Faces Copyright Lawsuit from Disney and Universal

San Francisco-based AI art generator Midjourney is embroiled in a high-profile copyright infringement lawsuit brought by entertainment giants Disney and Universal. The plaintiffs allege that Midjourney’s AI unlawfully generates images infringing on their copyrighted characters and properties, including Star Wars, Marvel, and The Simpsons. Disney and Universal argue that Midjourney acts as a "virtual vending machine" producing unauthorized copies of their intellectual property. In response, Midjourney’s attorneys have submitted a 43-page filing asserting that the company operates within fair use boundaries and criticizing the plaintiffs for simultaneously benefiting from AI tools like Midjourney.

AI Training, Fair Use, and Liability Issues

Midjourney’s legal defence hinges on distinguishing how its AI model learns from vast datasets versus simply copying copyrighted images. The company likens AI training to human learning—absorbing patterns and styles rather than memorizing specific artworks. Midjourney also emphasizes that it cannot identify infringing images without copyright owners providing notice under its takedown procedures. This highlights a key legal and practical challenge for AI companies: balancing innovation with respect for copyright while managing user-generated outputs. The case may shape how courts view AI’s role in creative processes, fair use exceptions, and liability allocation between AI platforms and end-users.

Navigating IP Risks in AI and Creative Tech

For startups leveraging generative AI, this lawsuit underscores the critical importance of robust IP policies and clear user agreements that address content ownership and infringement. Founders should implement transparent takedown procedures, educate users on permissible content, and monitor evolving copyright jurisprudence related to AI. Startups must also weigh the risks of hosting user-generated AI outputs that could implicate them in infringement claims, while advocating for legal frameworks that support innovation without eroding creators’ rights. Being proactive about compliance and responsive to rights holders can help mitigate litigation risks as the legal landscape around AI-generated content develops.

In addition to our newsletter we offer 60+ free legal templates for companies in the UK, Canada and the US. These include employment contracts, investment agreements and more