⚖️ Share Option Plans

The Importance of a Formal Share Option Plan

Issuing share options without a formal options plan in place can lead to significant legal and financial risks for startups. A formal option plan outlines the rules and structure for how share options are granted, exercised, and vested, providing clarity to both the company and the option holders. Without this structure, companies run the risk of inconsistent practices, which can lead to disputes over the terms of the options or confusion about the rights of the option holders. Additionally, regulators may view the issuance of options without a plan as non-compliant, which could trigger audits or penalties.

Tax and Compliance Risks

Issuing share options informally can also expose both the company and the option holders to unexpected tax liabilities. In many jurisdictions, there are specific tax rules that apply to employee stock options, and failure to adhere to these rules can result in punitive taxes for employees, potentially negating the benefits of the options altogether. Without an options plan, companies may fail to properly account for these tax implications, which can lead to issues during audits or funding rounds when investors scrutinize the company's legal and financial structure. A formal plan helps ensure compliance with local tax laws and reduces the risk of costly mistakes.

Investor Confidence and Future Funding

Finally, issuing share options without a plan can undermine investor confidence and complicate future fundraising efforts. Investors expect startups to have well-defined equity structures, including an options pool that is governed by a formal plan. If a company has been issuing options without a clear, documented process, it may raise red flags during due diligence, as investors may be concerned about potential liabilities or mismanagement. Establishing a proper options plan early on not only protects the company legally but also reassures investors that the startup is operating in a professional and compliant manner, setting the stage for smoother funding rounds.

In addition to our newsletter we offer 60+ free legal templates for companies in the UK, Canada and the US. These include employment contracts, investment agreements and more